(Courtesy of 20th Century Fox)

Courtesy of 20th Century Fox

The Greatest Showman disappointing viewers

March 15, 2018

In 2017, the musical genre became a crowd pleaser. As people devoted themselves to musicals such as Hamilton, it came as no surprise that movie makers would want to make films focused around musicals. While many were excited for The Greatest Showman, a movie musical directed by Michael Gracey, many viewers were left disappointed after watching the film, resulting in the movie, staring Hugh Jackman, Zendaya and Zac Efron, receiving a Rotten Tomatoes score of 50.

When Barnum gets fired from his job, he turns the bad into good and decides to create his own show, he seeks out people who have been treated poorly for the way they look to create a circus that turns characteristics that were deemed negative, into entertaining ones. Once the show created by P.T. Barnum becomes successful, there are unexpected problems each character must face. For example, Jackman’s character constantly has to decide whether he is happy with the success he has created or if he wants to make changes that will affect to his show. He must consider how the new additions to the show put restraints on both his family and the existing show he has created.

Throughout the entire movie, the characters often break out in song and dance making the movie seem unrelistic and cliche. The filmalso fails to give a sufficient  amount of background information  for any characters, except Barnum and his wife. There is especially a lack in description when it comes to the characters of Efron and Zendaya, Phillip Carlyle and Anne Wheeler, the two main artists that promoted the film. The audience does not know much about where they came from and how their relationship really began. Their relationship comes sudden and does not get focused on enough for the viewer to fully support the love.The multiracial relationship that was featured in The Greatest Showman was extremely rare in the time period set for the movie. Carlyle and Wheeler, are involved in the unusual relationship. The recently popular song, “Rewrite the Stars,” features the actors and united the two characters in the movie making the relationship feel real. This relationship helped in some ways make an emotional connection with the characters and the viewers.

The music featured in the movie is one of the main elements that was very disappointing. The setting of the movie is based in the 1800s, in contrast to this, the music sung and danced to is clearly from the 2000s. A musical should have music that coincides with the era that the film is based in and not modern music. Thevibe of the film is thrown off completewly and makes it hard for the audience to remeber that this film is not based in modern times.

Overall, The Greatest Showman did not do justice for the viewer. The lack of background and poor choice of music makes for an unsatisfactory movie and a complete let down for the overally promoted film. The targeted crowd of families or any people who love musicals will feel disappointed with the unrealistic movie that has been very heavily talked about. The unjust music and lack of background makes for a successfully distasteful musical.

About the Writer
Photo of Maddie Dufault
Maddie Dufault, Reporter

Maddie Dufault is a second year staff member and junior at Carlsbad High Schoo. She is involved in journalism because she appreciates and is grateful for...

1 Comment

One Response to “The Greatest Showman disappointing viewers”

  1. Mijipuff on June 22nd, 2019 5:17 am

    I think the move was awesome! I know that its based on older times its quite easy to recognise, I LOVE the choice of music, it’s still easy to tell that the movie is based back in the day even with the music, aka – the old buildings, where Barnum worked at, the posters, the outfits, the toys, the house decor, even some of the characters personalities, the movie wasn’t disappointing, you guys and other people judge it like you don’t wanna hear it or you don’t like it from your perspective ONE MOVIE is not gonna be for everyone and not everyone is going to like it even the most high rated movie producer, even my friends loved that movie, and two of them don’t, see not everyone has to abide by other people’s opinion, and every one has a different style, liking and opinion, well there you go there’s my opinion thanks for reading!

As a public forum for student expression, Lancer Link welcomes letters to the editor and comments on articles, but reserves the right to refuse inappropriate letters and comments.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




The Lancer Link • Copyright 2020 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in